The Philippines and beyond · RSS

Walang kuwento kung walang resibo.

‘Judicial Legislation’: Drilon urges Congress to challenge SC ruling on budget voids

Screencap Media PH

Former Senate President Franklin Drilon on Thursday said Congress must seek clarification from the Supreme Court on its ruling declaring parts of the 2024 and 2025 national budgets void, warning that the decision may encroach on the legislature’s authority over the budgeting process.

Based on his reading, Drilon said the High Court affirmed that unprogrammed appropriations are not unconstitutional in themselves, as they provide standby spending authority that may be exercised only when the government has excess funds.

Drilon, who also served as justice secretary, said seeking clarification from the Supreme Court is appropriate because the ruling, as currently written, may go beyond constitutional review by prescribing fiscal conditions that, under the 1987 Constitution, should be left to the best judgment of Congress.

He said the Supreme Court ruling directly affects the authority of Congress to determine appropriations.

“We look forward to seeing how the reforms will be reflected in the 2027 budget,” Drilon said.

Serving as an amicus curiae during the proceedings, Drilon defended the constitutionality of unprogrammed appropriations but warned that their implementation could violate constitutional limits.

He acknowledged that flaws and abuses in the mechanism may require correction, but stressed that the standards needed to address them should be expressly imposed by Congress through legislation, with the Court determining whether those standards comply with the Constitution.

He noted that identifying a constitutional defect does not necessarily authorize the Court to write budget guidelines that would replace the express conditions set by Congress.

Doing so, Drilon added, raises significant concerns regarding judicial legislation.

“Congress determines appropriations and their lawful conditions. The Executive implements the budget within those conditions. Both functions remain subject to the Constitution,” he also said.

Drilon emphasized that seeking clarification will help establish the boundaries of judicial review while preserving constitutional safeguards against the misuse of public funds.

“The concern therefore extends beyond one administration or one budget. It involves the scope of the budget powers available to future Congresses and Presidents,” he also added.

Meanwhile, Senate Committee on Finance Chairman Sen. Joseph Victor “JV” Ejercito warned that recalling the proposed national budget is not viable and could lead to a reenacted budget next year.

“Kapag yun ang nangyari, palagay ko malaki ang chance na hindi matapos ang budget. Very tight ang schedule natin you know that. Meron tayong impeachment magre-resume yan November 9. Meron tayong regular plenary, tapos may budget hearings pa,” Ejercito said in an interview.

Ejercito stated that the target date to finish the budget process, including the bicameral conference committee meetings, is set for the second week of December.

He said lawmakers will carefully examine the Supreme Court decision on unprogrammed appropriations to guide the final version of the budget bill.

“But we have to further study, tulad din ng DBM, itong SC decision so that yung ating preparation, implementation, and final budget version will be compliant at saka to make sure na walang infirmities that will be violative of the Constitution,” Ejercito said.

Ejercito noted that the Supreme Court decision was clear that unprogrammed appropriations remain constitutional as long as they stay within the President’s spending plan.

“So, we will subscribe. We will, of course, abide by the ruling of the Supreme Court,” he also said.

However, Ejercito indicated that the specific restriction prohibiting the use of excess revenues for unprogrammed appropriations may need to be reconsidered.

“I think it has to be utilized kasi sayang naman. It can be used for other purposes, just in case…So, ako po, on that provision, I think it has to be reconsidered…Kasi paano naman natin ma-a-access yung excess revenues kung we will be prohibited? Dadaan pa sa Congress ulit, hihingi ng supplemental budget. Mukhang mas mahirap yun, especially when there are things that need immediate action,” Ejercito said.

“We have to abide by the decision now, but it will be appealed…I will support the appeal so that we can use the excess revenues,” he also added.